Black cohosh is an herb from the root of a North American plant. People take it to ease menopause symptoms like hot flashes, night sweats and mood changes. It is usually taken as a capsule, tablet or liquid extract.
Every report comes from a Lived member, sent anonymously.
Have you tried Black Cohosh for Menopause?
Black cohosh is a North American plant in the buttercup family. Supplements are made from its root and underground stem, and are sold mainly to ease menopause symptoms such as hot flashes and night sweats. It is not a hormone, and studies of the extracts used in research have not found that it raises estrogen levels. People usually consider it because they want relief from hot flashes without taking hormone therapy, either by preference or because hormones are not a good option for them. It is also promoted for menstrual cramps, premenstrual symptoms and bringing on labor, but those uses rest on tradition and marketing rather than reliable evidence.
Research on black cohosh for menopause is extensive but inconsistent. A Cochrane review of 16 trials in about 2,000 women found no clear difference from a placebo (a dummy pill) in how often hot flashes occurred or in overall symptom scores, and hormone therapy worked better than black cohosh. A later analysis that also counted products combining black cohosh with other herbs found some improvement in overall symptoms and hot flashes, but not in anxiety or low mood. European regulators accept black cohosh extracts as herbal medicines for hot flashes and sweating based on long use and published studies, though researchers note that a benefit clearly larger than placebo has been hard to demonstrate. In practice, any benefit is likely to be modest and uneven from person to person. The Menopause Society does not recommend herbal supplements for hot flashes. Hormone therapy remains the most effective treatment, and several nonhormone prescription options and cognitive behavioral therapy have stronger evidence. Whether black cohosh helps hot flashes caused by breast cancer treatment is uncertain, and there is not enough evidence to judge it for cramps, premenstrual symptoms or other uses.
Black cohosh comes as tablets, capsules and liquid extracts. Products differ in how the root is extracted and how much they contain, so one brand's dose does not translate directly to another's. Most trials used a standardized single-herb extract at around 40 mg a day, often split into two doses, for several months. Combination products that mix black cohosh with soy, St. John's wort or other herbs are not covered by most of that research. Because long-term safety studies are lacking, European guidance says black cohosh medicines are for adult women and should not be taken for longer than 6 months without checking with a doctor. If symptoms are no better after a reasonable trial, or get worse, that is a reason to revisit the plan rather than raise the dose.
Black cohosh is usually well tolerated in studies lasting up to a year. The most common complaints are stomach upset, such as nausea, indigestion or diarrhea, along with headache, rash or itching, and some swelling of the face, hands or legs. Higher amounts are more likely to cause dizziness or vomiting. The main concern is rare liver damage, which in a few reported cases was severe enough to cause liver failure. It is not certain that black cohosh itself was responsible, since some products have contained other herbs, but the possibility is taken seriously by regulators. Stop taking it and contact your doctor right away if you notice unusual tiredness, loss of appetite, yellowing of the skin or eyes, dark urine, or pain in the upper stomach with nausea and vomiting.
People with liver disease, or who take medicines that can strain the liver, should talk with a clinician before using black cohosh. Anyone with a history of breast or uterine cancer should do the same, because safety after hormone-sensitive cancers is uncertain. That includes people taking tamoxifen, a breast cancer medicine, since black cohosh may slightly affect how the body processes it. Black cohosh may not be safe during pregnancy or breastfeeding, and it should not be used to bring on labor without medical supervision. Black cohosh is not the same as blue cohosh, a different herb that can raise blood pressure and has caused serious harm to newborns when used to induce labor. Check the label for the plant name Actaea racemosa or Cimicifuga racemosa. In the US, supplements are not approved by the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) before sale, and some black cohosh products have been found to contain the wrong herb or herbs not listed on the label. A product with third-party quality testing reduces, but does not remove, that risk.
Educational content, not medical advice.
Share your experience taking Black Cohosh, what you've noticed, or ask the community a question.