Subchondral Arthroplasty

This is a type of surgery done on joints. It helps fix problems with the cartilage, which is the smooth tissue covering the ends of bones in a joint. The surgeon might use a small tool to drill into the bone underneath the cartilage to help it heal or to add new cartilage. Sometimes, they might use a piece of the patient's own tissue or a donor tissue to cover the cartilage.

Procedure

What people who've had Subchondral Arthroplasty report

Every report comes from a Lived member, sent anonymously.

Have you had Subchondral Arthroplasty for Cartilage Diseases?

NameHow it went

About Subchondral Arthroplasty

Who It's For

Subchondral arthroplasty is a group of operations that try to help damaged joint cartilage regrow. Cartilage is the smooth, slippery layer covering the ends of bones where they meet, and because it has no blood supply of its own it heals poorly. In these procedures the surgeon clears away the damaged cartilage and then breaches the hard bone just beneath it (the subchondral bone), either by tapping small holes with a pointed tool called an awl (microfracture), by drilling small holes, or by shaving the surface with a high-speed burr (abrasion arthroplasty). Blood and cells from the bone marrow flow into the defect and gradually form repair tissue called fibrocartilage. Fibrocartilage fills the gap and can ease pain, but it is not as tough or long-lasting as the original cartilage. The knee is the joint treated most often, though the ankle, shoulder and elbow can also be treated. The procedure suits a single, fairly small area of full-thickness cartilage damage, often after an injury, in a younger person or someone whose activities place moderate demands on the joint. It is not a treatment for widespread osteoarthritis. People with many damaged areas or established arthritis are less likely to benefit, and arthritis symptoms remain after surgery. The alternatives depend on the size of the damage and how active the person is. Arthroscopic debridement, which trims loose cartilage without opening into the bone, is simpler, and in a 2025 randomized trial of small knee lesions it gave results similar to microfracture after two years, with fewer complications. Larger defects, or very active people, may do better with procedures that supply more durable cartilage: implanting a person's own cartilage cells grown in a laboratory (matrix-induced autologous chondrocyte implantation, sold as MACI), or transplanting plugs of cartilage and bone from a less important part of the same joint or from a donor. Because a previous microfracture can make a later cartilage transplant less successful, surgeons weigh whether it is the right first step.

Before the Procedure

Cartilage does not show on ordinary X-rays, so a magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) scan is often used to judge the damage. The final decision is frequently made during the operation, when the surgeon can see the defect's size and depth and the condition of the bone beneath it. Other problems found at the same time, such as a torn meniscus or ligament, may be treated in the same operation, so it is worth asking beforehand what the surgeon plans to do if things look different than expected. Preparation is similar to other arthroscopic joint surgery. Tell the surgical team about every medicine and supplement you take, any recent illness, and whether you are or could be pregnant. You may be asked to pause medicines that make bleeding more likely, such as aspirin, ibuprofen (Advil, Motrin), naproxen (Aleve) and vitamin E; ask which to stop and which to take on the day of surgery. People with diabetes or heart disease may need a check with the clinician who manages that condition. Smoking slows wound and bone healing, so stopping helps. Expect instructions not to eat or drink for several hours beforehand, and arrange a ride home. Because recovery from a knee procedure usually involves several weeks on crutches, planning ahead pays off: set up your home so everyday essentials are reachable, line up help with errands and driving, and talk with your employer about time off or lighter duties.

During the Procedure

Most of these procedures are done by arthroscopy, through two or three small cuts around the joint. Anesthesia may be general (you are asleep), spinal (you are awake but numb below the waist), or a nerve block that numbs the leg, often combined with sedation or lighter general anesthesia. Sterile fluid is pumped into the joint to expand it, and a thin camera called an arthroscope shows the inside of the joint on a monitor. The surgeon removes loose and damaged cartilage until the defect has stable edges, then opens the bone beneath it. With microfracture, small holes are tapped across the defect, typically a few millimeters apart and a few millimeters deep. Drilling makes similar holes with a drill or wire, and abrasion shaves the bone surface with a burr. Blood and marrow then seep into the defect. At the end, the fluid is drained and the small cuts are closed and bandaged. Most people go home the same day.

Recovery & Aftercare

The early weeks are about protecting the repair while the clot in the defect matures into fibrocartilage. For a knee, this usually means keeping weight off the leg for about 6 to 8 weeks using crutches, unless the surgeon advises otherwise. Many people also use a continuous passive motion (CPM) machine, which slowly bends and straightens the knee for several hours a day, most often for about 6 weeks, because gentle movement helps the new tissue form and limits stiffness. Protocols vary with the joint and the location of the defect, so the surgeon's plan for weight and motion is the one to follow. Pain and swelling are normal at first. Raising the leg, using ice as directed and taking pain medicine before pain builds all help. A nerve block from surgery can wear off quickly, so start pain medicine before it does. Do not drive while taking opioid pain medicine. Physical therapy progresses from regaining motion to strengthening over 3 to 6 months. Return to everyday activities is gradual, and returning to running, jumping or pivoting sports often takes about 9 to 12 months. Some athletes in high-impact sports do not get back to their previous level. People under about 40 with a recent injury, and people who are not overweight, tend to have the best results. Call the surgeon right away for swelling or pain in the calf (a possible blood clot), bleeding that soaks through the dressing and does not stop with pressure, or a foot or toes that look darker than normal or feel cool. Sudden shortness of breath or chest pain can mean a clot has reached the lungs: call 911. Also contact the surgical team for pain that keeps getting worse despite pain medicine, redness, swelling or yellowish discharge at the incisions, or a temperature above 101°F (38.3°C).

Risks & Complications

The main limitation is durability. Fibrocartilage is less resilient than the original cartilage and can wear down, and the damaged area can slowly enlarge. Studies show that pain and function usually improve over the first two years, especially for small defects in younger people, but results often decline after about five years. In a review of people followed for 10 years or more after knee microfracture for medium to large defects (roughly 2 to 4 square centimeters), 40 to 48 percent showed X-ray signs of progressing arthritis, and a minority eventually needed a total knee replacement, with rates varying widely between studies. Breaching the subchondral bone can leave small fluid-filled cysts in the bone beneath the repair, which is one reason a later cartilage transplant can be less successful. Knee stiffness can also develop. As with any arthroscopy, there are uncommon risks of joint infection, bleeding into the joint, blood clots in the leg, injury to a nearby nerve or blood vessel, and reactions to anesthesia. Against these limits, each of these procedures is a single, widely available and less involved operation, while the alternatives that supply more durable cartilage usually involve a larger incision, donor tissue, or two separate surgeries.

Questions to Ask Your Doctor

  1. 1.Is my cartilage damage small and contained enough for microfracture, or would a cell implant or graft be more likely to last?
  2. 2.Would physical therapy or a simpler debridement be a reasonable first step for me?
  3. 3.If the damage looks different during surgery, what will you do, and how would that change my recovery?
  4. 4.How long will I be on crutches, will I need a CPM machine, and when can I expect to return to work, driving and sport?
  5. 5.What results do you see five or ten years after this procedure in people of my age and activity level?

Last reviewed • Oct 2026

Educational content, not medical advice.